| [This article first appeared in
MicroMath Volume 13/3 Autumn 1997. The screen shots are actually from a
TI-83. All instructions fit either calculator.]
It was the week before Xmas and the Upper Sixth
had just returned after a study leave period. The next topic in the scheme of
work was continuous distributions, discrete ones having been explored for
several weeks previously. The school had just acquired an OHP TI82 screen for
use with the set of TI82's. The following describes what turned into an
excellent set of lessons which I will certainly repeat. Firstly we needed
some data. Having done some work many years ago working on a project modelling
military manoeuvres I came up with the idea of parachute drops. The class made
their own parachutes out of carrier bags (a circle cut round a large dinner
plate), string and a weighted cardboard cut-out Santa Claus (chocolate ones
would have been better it was suggested!). A point was marked on the ceiling
and a plumb line dropped to give another mark directly below. The parachutes
were then held up to the ceiling mark and released and their distance from the
'drop zone' measured. This was repeated 50 times. The following was one set of
data - all the groups however got remarkably good bell shaped distributions
although the parameters varied according to various design elements in the
parachute.
The following lesson this set was used as an example. Everyone put
the data in their TI82 (the first use any had made of these) and after
adjusting the scaling under WINDOW first a Box & Whisker and then a
histogram was drawn. Having the screen of my calculator displayed on the white
board was very reassuring for the students in knowing they had done the right
thing - a few minor problems were sorted where awkward MODE's had been
left in. The class were then told that the purpose of the lesson was to try
and find a mathematical model to fit this data. 'Inverse quadratic' came up
fairly quickly and after some discussion the graph of y = - x2 was
sketched on the whiteboard in position on the histogram axis displayed by the
OHP. After several suggestions and trials by the students the quadratic was
shifted, enlarged and stretched sideways to give a curve that the students
agreed was probably the best they were going to get from a quadratic:-
  One student
suggested a split function with the inverse quadratic up to say x = 35 and then
a positive quadratic to give a nice tail at the end. All agreed that this was a
good idea but a bit clumsy. " The trouble with all of these", said one student,
"is that they will all cut the x-axis at some point but in reality they need to
got to infinity, " What if the parachute had caught a draught.?" " You need
something like a sine curve", said another. At this we proceeded to fit a
suitable sine function, although it was pointed out that this still cut the
x-axis. At this point I gave some direction by looking at curves which tailed
off to infinity, 1/x was suggested by the class We switched off
theSTATPLOT at this point and I suggested they look for a function which
gave a positive and negative infinite tail. After arriving at ex and
e-x and discussing how we could combine them into one function I
suggested that Gauss faced with the same problem had come up with
exp[-x2] and there was an almost universal hum of approval as
they saw the bell shaped curve it produced. We then returned to the
STATPLOT histogram and with very little prompting they were able to add
various constants to produce the following model which they all agreed was an
eminently good fit.
  Several students
commented at the end how they had seen that day the purpose of 'all that graph
plotting they had done in the Lower Sixth'. By the end all were confidently
using the TI82's which were previously unfamiliar to them. In the new year
it is planned to spend a further lesson to finally bring this round to
p.d.f.'s. By looking at the area using the integral function (Option 7: under
CALC) the total area under the curve can be found. Functions can then be
divided by this area as a constant that will give a probability function. Once
done the integral can be used to work out areas that will give the probability
of a value lying in a particular range.

All such modelling exercises
should end up with a simulation. Using random numbers to generate distances
from the spot ( perhaps a rectangular distribution to give a bearing?) a series
of spots can be placed an a scaled diagrams to give,( hopefully) a realistic
picture of what went on in practice. Many thanks to my colleagues
Bryan Dye, and Crisp Wilmington for their technical assistance in setting up
the lessons.
|